wow!!!!!!!!!!
I finally found someone had the same problem as me
I have a 120 GB Western Digital , i was using it since around 5 month and everything was looking fine . i had (2 instances of Win Xp proffessional + Mandrake 10 linux ) installed on it , then on one day while i was working and after pc was updating windows xp with sp2 the pc asked for restart so i restarted then after logging in (the same system that asked for restart) for few second the pc hanged so i pushed restart button..
AND GUESS WHAT... I was asked about the damn password !!!!
Anyhow for me the probelm was not that easy because i didn't knew that a hard disk password thing does exist although i was using PC for years (even before pentium ) and the motherboard doesn't ask for password in a clear way it just stops while booting and allow me to write something (this thing is written in astrsicks and is 32 bit length and after five trials it stops accepting anymore trials) i spent days searching and trying to write a new MBR or accessing the hard disk using a low level tools as Norton disk edit but i couldn't.
till i used Western Digital disk which boots from Dos i tried to partition the disk so it tols me : The Disk is locked please unlock it first.....
so i googled for this error message and here i started to learn about the ATA Stanard Build in security and all that issues...
Conclusions i had made till now:
1- The Password is written on the platter meaning that even changing the ata controller will make no use.
2- although the password is firmware but
There is a software solution for this problem but it is considered a secret known only by data storage companies..
I found companies offering remove of password without voiding any type of warranty (meaning they won't open the Hard disk) for 89$ but you should send it to them in Canada,
and other companies offer to remove the password over the internet without even pulling the disk ut of your computer ( for 149$)
3- Now i am getting more certain that this problem is caused by a virus that is not yet know by antivirus companies ... why?
a- you had the problem with segate and i had it with WD thus it is not a manefacturer bug.
b- We had the problem at nearly the same time which means it is a new virus.
c- setting a hard disk password isn't hard at all and there is a lot of tools that already make it (as ATAPWD )
d- Viruses usually takes in consideration a method to spread and that's why antivirus companies can easily find them but this virus is actually killing itself because it just lock the hard disk to which it reach.
e- The other option is that i was hacked but i really find it difficult as i had (Full Mcafee security center which include antivirus, firewall,spamkiller, privacy service)
4- By the way ATAPWD won't unlock the harddisk without providing it with the password and leaving the password empty won't work.
I think that you it was a bug reported by a company that make firmwares that sometimes their firmwares reports a lock with empty password ( ithink i read your quote somewhere when i was searching)
i hope we get in contact more may be we can understand the cause of the problem
Note: i used another PC that has a motherboard doesn't recongnize ATA passwords this allowed me to run win Xp while making the locked hard disk a slave so that i can try all these tools (ATAPWD ...etc) anyhow, this won't give you acceess to the locked disk it will onlu be recognized and the disk reports its geometry but without allowin read/write access to it.