Thanks guys - you all gave some really valid and interesting input.
Everyone's pretty much touched on the concept of "themes", "breaking pages up", "pages with logical themes" and "tighter focus on keywords".
Ok, so let's then take this quote from Gardenstew then
tighly themed pages rather than one page with a bunch of themes
and this one from phaugh
pages topic might be diluted due to all the text being lumped together
My question is - when do themes start to become separate from each other to justify the creation of individual pages for each?
For example, say hypothetically we have a page (word count ~1900, page size ~19K) playing on the keywords
car touring,
race drivers,
motor racing,
fa1 and
Grand Prix racing. It's page title is something like Car and Motor Racing.
Would you look at this from phaugh's perspective and say that the page topic (ie, title) would be diluted by the large word count? Do we take gardenstew's opinion and break this page up into 4-5 smaller pages each centering on a keyword as the page title (eg F1), with variations of the title for additional keywords (Ferrari racing team, German Grand Prix, Forumla One rules, etc).
Yes, from a surfers perspective it would be nicer to find all this information on one page where you could simply scroll down and read.
But from a SEO perspective it would be nice to split this page up, where we could utilise keyword rich text links between the pages, add to our overall site page count, faster page loading, the chance to employ a lot more keywords.
Then again, who says we just can't stick with the one page having multiple themes and multiple keywords. Why can't we just cram masses of keywords (related of course) on page if they relate to the same type of topics/themes? What would goggle think of this vs breaking the page up into smaller ones (even though the sum of their keywords and content would equal the one page itself!) Make sense?
To me it all seems a much of a muchness. Sure, there are advantages (technically speaking), but where do we put a stop to this SEO madness.
Google, you have a lot to answer for....
My brain's starting to fry.....I've got to go
cya guys